PDA

View Full Version : Are Sens putting up fight for toughness?


Man.Utd
8-07-05, 12:38 PM
By DON BRENNAN -- Ottawa Sun

The Senators must think AHL penalty-minute king Brian McGrattan is ready for prime time.

Either that, or they're going to make a sudden pitch for former Hull Olympiques bouncer Peter Worrell and are being very secretive about it. Surely, it's not that John Muckler and Bryan Murray have changed their minds about the need to make the team tougher. There just had to be a good reason they didn't even bother to talk with Andre Roy.

"It would be fun, I really loved my time in Ottawa and it's not very far from my home (in St-Jerome, Que.)," Roy said earlier this week about a possible return to the Senators -- before he signed a three-year, $1-million (all terms US) a season contract with the Pittsburgh Penguins.

"You always want to be part of a Cup contender, and if Ottawa makes a pitch for sure I'd listen.

"I've had lots of phone calls. Nine or 10 teams are interested, and there's a race between four that sound really serious. Last I heard Ottawa wasn't one of them."

By no means would Roy represent a major signing. He is what he is. A role player. A fighter. A physical presence with some offensive skills and some defensive shortcomings. But he also now owns a Stanley Cup ring -- dressing for 21 playoff games with the championship winning Tampa Bay Lightning -- and he was a fan favourite here before Jacques Martin moved him out of town.

Landing him would have been a popular move by the Senators.

With Chris Neil still an unsigned restricted free agent, Zdeno Chara is the only Senator under contract who doesn't mind dropping the gloves and they need him on the ice.

MISSING GRIT

Maybe, just maybe, with Neil in tow they might be able to get by without a third. What they absolutely do require, however, is the grit that could have been provided by a Darren McCarty (now a Calgary Flame) or Martin Lapointe (Chicago) -- but it's no surprise they didn't vigorously pursue either. McCarty plays the right side, where they are already deep, and Lapointe, who despite making almost $3 million a year less than he did on his last contract, is still overpriced after landing $7.2 million over three years from the Blackhawks.

Meanwhile, the Senators could also use something to excite their fans.

The unprecedented free-agent frenzy that has dominated the headlines is exactly what the NHL needed. In many a city, the good folk who were hurt most by the lockout/strike are being tantalized with signings that represent new hope. Aside from the pre-league shutdown addition of Dominik Hasek, a 40-year-old, injury-troubled goalie who has played only 14 games in the last three-and-a-half years, and the recent re-signing of minor-leaguer Denis Hamel who may or may not crack their lineup, the Senators have done nothing.

The Senators may be focused on re-signing their own free agents -- which includes restricted free agents Marian Hossa, Martin Havlat and Mike Fisher -- as they have a mere 11 under contract. The team could even possibly be looking into trying to lock up Chara and Wade Redden, who both become unrestricted free agents after this season, and Chris Phillips, who will be unrestricted two years from now.

But this is a team that, when last we saw it, was again losing a first-round playoff series to the Leafs. It needs some outside assistance.

Hoping that your young core will be better this time around is not enough. The Senators need to make a positive move and bring in a new face or two, either by trade or free-agent signings. Still on the market are the likes of Andrew Cassels, Teemu Selanne and Vincent Damphousse.

Or maybe they'd be best off just to see what it would take to sign Chris Gratton, a 6-foot-3, 220-lb. centre who had his $1.9-million contract bought out by Colorado, or unrestricted free agent Eric Lindros. He wouldn't solve all that ails the Senators, but he would help answer any toughness questions still hovering over the team.

Man.Utd
8-07-05, 12:47 PM
Thank God the media doesn't run this team. Our whole roster would be shipped off for inferior, but grittier players. This time the B.O.O. wasn't lost due to grit - we more than held our own. It was decided by the difference in goaltending, some of our offensive guys failing to produce, and some very questionable coaching descisions.

Since Ottawa just doesn't have the cap room to add a big, all-star calibre powerforward all we need is a second-line gritty LW'er who can score a bit too. Put him on the first line and watch him get inflated offensive statisitcs. Let's just say for arguments Gary Roberts signed here. It immediatly gives us an gritty, not too far from imposing, line-up. I mean, our bottom-six is fine, our D one of the biggest and meanest in the league, and we have a goalie who's too aggressive for his own good at times in Emery. And we're one groin pull away from seeing Razor play quite a bit of hockey (unfortunatly).

Roberts - Spezza - Alfredsson
Havlat - Smolinski - Hossa
Fisher - Vermette - Varada
Scaefer - Kelly - Neil

There. Every line has a phsyical presence, in our bottom-six two of them, excluding our second line. But that is so skilled for a second unit it more than makes up for it. Not to mention Havlat has bulked up quite a bit this extended off-season and can aggitate while Hossa is a great big body presence despite not being a punishing player.

Newfie John
8-07-05, 3:46 PM
Judging from the AHL, Mcgratton is ready. I seen him beat the crap out of a few guys, including NHL enforcers. One of them was Nathan Perrot, though Perrot got his redemption.

Man.Utd
8-07-05, 4:20 PM
Judging from the AHL, Mcgratton is ready. I seen him beat the crap out of a few guys, including NHL enforcers. One of them was Nathan Perrot, though Perrot got his redemption.

Yeah. If Ottawa wants another bottom-line enforcer I'd much rather promote McGratton at the league minimum than pay 800k+ for a UFA scrapper.

PDO
8-07-05, 4:28 PM
Need grit eh?

I'll trade you Laraque for Havlat :thumb:

Seriously though... grit is by far the most over-rated aspect in hockey. While it pay's off occasionally, inferior players are highly touted because they're willing to have their face broken.

MadDevil
8-07-05, 5:56 PM
The thing I've never understood is why some people in the media say year after year that the Sens need to get "tougher and grittier". With guys like Alfredsson, Hossa, Havlat, Spezza, Chara, Redden, etc. some 4th liner whose willing to drop the gloves is going to push them over the edge? I don't think so.

Face it, some teams just go through stretches of bad luck. One of these days, if they keep running their organization they way they have, the Sens will be rewarded with a Cup. My guess would be that in the next 3-4 years, the Sens will have won a championship, and it won't have been a 4th line enforcer that was the reason. Just my opinion though.

Man.Utd
8-07-05, 6:34 PM
Need grit eh?

I'll trade you Laraque for Havlat :thumb:

Seriously though... grit is by far the most over-rated aspect in hockey. While it pay's off occasionally, inferior players are highly touted because they're willing to have their face broken.

Bingo. Is it any wonder that most of the moves to push teams over the top have always been the ones that send AWAY the girtty players. Quite often in exchange for a good deefenseman, but not always.

- Deadmarsh to LA for Blake. Avs win the Cup that same year.
- Arnott/McKay/pick to Dallas for Langenbrunner and Nieuwendyk. Devils win the Cup that same year.
- Svivtov/pick to Columbus for Sydor/pick. Tampa wins the cup that same season.

Just something I've notcied off the top of my head. If I looked I'm sure I could find plenty more examples. It's just easier to remember those being mor e recent. The players who push clubs over the top are always quite skilled, but usually not "gritty". Infact, the so called "gritty" player is usually sent in exchange.

You do need a mix, but our mix is good enough. A girtty, top-six LW'er would do wonders simply because we're quite weak on the left side and it wouldn't hurt to add some sand-paper in the process. You know, kill two birds with one stone. But beyond that we're fine as far as grit goes.

I may take some heat for this, but had Ottawa a guy like Brodeur/Roy/Khabibulin/Belfour between the pipes these past years - all the goalies who have taken their teams to Cups recently - in place of our make-shift starters we would have won at least one Cup win by now. Maybe even two. Our lack of legit, #1 netminding has hurt us far more than our lack of an all-star powerforward.

macca
8-08-05, 10:31 AM
I may take some heat for this, but had Ottawa a guy like Brodeur/Roy/Khabibulin/Belfour between the pipes these past years - all the goalies who have taken their teams to Cups recently - in place of our make-shift starters we would have won at least one Cup win by now. Maybe even two. Our lack of legit, #1 netminding has hurt us far more than our lack of an all-star powerforward.


I agree. Goaltending has been the main reason why Ottawa has not advanced to the Stanley Cup, especially in the last couple of years. Ottawa has had capable (average) goaltending, but average goaltending is usually not going to be good enough in the playoffs. Last year I think Ottawa matched Toronto hit for hit during that gruelling series and both teams took a physical pounding. The main difference in that series was Belfour. Having said that, many of Ottawa shots on net were from the parameter and Belfour always saw the puck. None of Ottawa's centres, with the exception of Fisher who Martin refused to play much and Bonk who never left the neutral zone, were big enough to cause a problem in front of the other teams net and bang in rebounds. When Toronto played the Flyers, the Flyers parked Primeau and others in front of Belfour and harrassed him constantly, and by the 3rd or 4th game Belfour looked like swiss cheese. So I don't think grit has been a problem with the Sens especially in the last few years, but size and a physical presence at centre ice has been a problem. Now whether or not the new rules help Ottawa remains to be seen, you'd think the new rules would definitely help players like Smolinksi, Vermette and Spezza. Of course my main concern is whether the NHL will start the season calling obstruction, and then by January we'll all be watching rugby on ice again. Because if that happens I think Ottawa will be in trouble.